Income Tax, Gift & Estate Tax Issues
Tips for Art Collectors & Artists
For more information about artist estate planning, read Artist Tips: Checklist for Planning Your Art Estate
For IRS rules and regulations on estate and gift taxes click here.
Q: Please talk about the artist and estate taxes, gift tax, donations, and other IRS tax liabilities and implications for art, artists and collectors. What can an artist or collector do who will be leaving a large number of paintings or other works of art at the time of his or her death?
A: This is a relatively complex field, but a few basic tips will come in handy for just about everyone. Before getting started, any reasonably successful artist who waits too long to figure out how much estate tax their descendents may owe can be in for a seriously unpleasant financial awakening. Estate planning should begin as soon as possible especially if your art sells for significant amounts of money and you've been accumulating increasing amounts of it. To the Internal Revenue Service, successful means that your entire estate, art included, is valued at over $5,450,000 (for the 2016 tax year). Under that amount, you have nothing to worry about taxwise, at least at the federal level. Over that amount, better line up a good accountant, an art attorney familiar with tax implications, an art appraiser or related professional advisors because the current tax rate on anything in excess of that amount is 40%. In 2016, the maximum total dollar amount that can be passed down in the family or given tax-free as gifts is $5,450,000 million for an individual ($10,900,000 for a married couple). Before continuing, please note that I am neither an attorney nor an accountant and this article does not constitute legal advice; please consult qualified professionals familiar with IRS tax laws and procedures for answers to your questions.
The single best device for passing on property and minimizing estate taxes is by giving non-taxable gifts during your lifetime. According to IRS regulations, you can give a maximum of $14,000 for the year 2016 without being taxed to any single individual, charity, museum or other entity, except to an employee or as an incentive to enter into a business transaction. For example, you might decide to give $14,000 worth of art to each of the following: three children, fifteen grandchildren, five nephews and nieces, four charities, three museums, your hairdresser, the man who repairs your car and the woman who delivers your mail. In case you're counting, that's $462,000 that won't be included in any estate tax calculations made at the time of your death. The good news is that you don't have to wait until the end is nigh. If you're feeling generous, you can give those $14000 individual tax-free gifts away anytime you feel like it.
In order to avoid any confusion as to when gifts are given, supply the IRS with full documentation as to dates, recipients and dollar amounts by filing the proper documentation-- Form 709, United States Gift and Generation-Skipping Transfer Tax Return (don't worry, it's not complicated). If you wish to give gifts or donations of over $14,000, particularly to museums or charities or other registered nonprofits, you'll need to consult a qualified tax accountant or consultant to determine whether you can work out any type of arrangement where the fair market appreciated value of that gift can be taken as a tax deduction. As of 2016, artists are still not allowed to take fair market value deductions when donating their own work while alive (they can only deduct cost of materials), however their estates can deduct fair market value after their deaths. Owners of art other than the artists who made it can take fair market value for the art whether or not the artist is alive-- including artists who donate the work of other artists-- but certain rules, conditions and restrictions apply, so always consult qualified professionals on these matters first.
Now for the sticky part: How do you determine the fair market value of the art you're gifting or donating? According to Internal Revenue Code, fair market value is defined as "the price that property would sell for on the open market. It is the price that would be agreed on between a willing buyer and a willing seller, with neither being required to act, and both having reasonable knowledge of the relevant facts." With art, dollar amounts are not written in stone. Nevertheless, how you interpret or determine prices may well be scrutinized by the IRS which means that you have to be careful in stating dollar values. The IRS has the right to challenge valuations on any gifts of over $5000 for a period of four years after they've been given so do your best to be accurate in your values, and in case anyone asks, make sure you're able to explain them based on facts about the market for your art.
Consulting a professional appraiser and paying for an appraisal is highly advisable if you have any questions as to how to value your art, and is required for donations of over $5000. FYI, You can reduce appraisal bills by maintaining accurate records that show how your art repeatedly changing hands in the marketplace for comparable amounts to what you claim it's worth as gifts or donations. The more of these records you have, the less work the appraiser has to do and the less they have to bill you for research.
Certain valuation problems can and do arise on a regular basis. For example, when artists or collectors give art to close friends, family or relatives, their natural inclinations are to give as much as possible and value it as low as possible in order to maximize the amounts they can give tax-free. On the other hand, when people donate art to museums, charities, or similar institutions, their natural inclinations are to give as little as possible and value it as high as possible in order to maximize their income, gift or estate tax deductions. The Internal Revenue Service is well aware of both inclinations and will review how the art has been valued if they think something strange is going on. Both you and your appraiser can be penalized for misstating dollar values on tax returns, so be accurate and be able to support donation valuations with facts about the current markets for the art. Again, keep in mind that the artist cannot personally take fair market value when donating or gifting their own art; someone other than the artist can take full value, however certain restrictions apply so consult a professional on this matter.
For those of you whose net worth will still be well in excess of $5,450,000 regardless of how much art you gift or donate during your lifetime, there are ways to minimize estate taxes at the time of your death. Without getting bogged down in technical details and previous court rulings, here are several variables that normally come into play:
* The salability of the art. Art that is highly salable or in great demand by collectors is worth more than art that takes longer to sell, even though they both may eventually sell for comparable amounts of money. In other words, "slow sellers" may under certain conditions be appraised lower than "fast sellers."
* The "bulk discount" phenomenon. Hypothetically, if all of the art in an estate is placed up for sale or dumped onto the market at once, there will be more art than collectors able to absorb it, overall prices will drop and each individual piece will therefore be worth less. Viewed from this perspective, an estate can be appraised lower than the sum total of the current retail values totaled on a piece-by-piece basis. "Bulk discount" appraisals have met with a certain degree of success when challenged in court.
* Auction vs retail value. Art generally sells for less at auction than it does at retail galleries which means that appraising it at auction values (generally considered to be in the vicinity of FMV or fair market value) is often (but not always) more representative of its true transactionary value than appraising it at retail levels. Keep in mind that for IRS purposes, fair market values are required, not retail gallery values. There is a certain flexibility when determining where in the range of auction vs retail a work of art is valued, but remember that penalties do apply if the appraisal is reviewed and the IRS concludes that the art has been valued either too high or too low.
* With respect to drawings, sketches, notebooks, incomplete works, or similar less significant pieces, artists can ordinarily ascribe relatively minimal values to these items. They do not necessarily have to be categorized as significant finished works of art.
The bottom line here is that if your estate is substantial, you'd better start planning for its tax implications and dispersal immediately. Get names of qualified appraisers, attorneys and tax consultants from fellow artists, preferably those whose levels of success approximate your own. If your estate is extremely substantial, such as Warhol's or Mapplethorpe's, chances are good that valuations will be contested in one form or another no matter what you do so make doubly sure you have quality people working on your behalf and have good solid substantiated defensible explanations as to why your art has been valued the way it has.
With every professional you contact, fully review and discuss your options and preferences for passing on your art. Don't simply show them a pile of art and expect them to automatically know what to do. Have things sorted, organized and documented as best as you can. Be prepared to tell them everything you can including details about the extent and history of your career, your sales history, your typical selling prices, the current market for your art, who you would like to receive what, what you want to happen to the bulk of your estate, and anything else regarding your long term aspirations.
Thanks to the Internal Revenue Service, to Helen Milowe of Friedman, Olive & McCubbin in San Francisco, and to the Trusts & Estates Department of Bonhams Butterfields auction house for their assistance with this article.
Disclaimer: This article is not intended to provide legal or tax advice. If you have estate or tax questions, contact a qualified professional such as an attorney, accountant, tax advisor or the IRS for assistance.
(painting by Peter & Madeline Powell)
Services for Artists and Collectors
- Art Consulting From Me Helps You >>